☎ 217-671-6171

Pool Care Blog

Automatic vs. Mesh vs. Solid Pool Covers for Illinois Winters

For a pool in this climate, a cover is a safety layer and a winter tool, not a thing you think about in October.

Lincoln, IL · Monday–Friday, 9 AM–5 PM · Closed weekends

How automatic, mesh, and solid covers behave in a Central Illinois winter, and which job each one is actually good at.

Written by the crew at Legacy Backyards in Lincoln. [NEEDS INFO: author name and credentials, or who on the team should be named as the reviewer.]

For a pool in this climate, a cover is a safety layer and a winter tool, not a thing you think about in October. An automatic safety cover is convenient, and when you use a cover pump and hold the right water level, it can stay on year-round. A mesh safety cover is a common anchored winter cover. Water can pass through, and you'll do more cleanup in the spring. A solid safety cover blocks more light and debris, but it holds water that has to be pumped off. None of them replaces a fence, or you watching the yard.

See also pool covers, closing, winter care, and the cover pump.

Automatic pool cover closed over an inground pool installed by Legacy Backyards
Mesh safety cover installed on an inground pool by Legacy Backyards

What a cover has to do here

Our winters involve snow, ice, thaw, wind, and leaves. A cover that works in a mild climate can still fail here if it's undersized, poorly anchored, or used with the wrong water level. If you need a safety cover, get one that's designed as a safety cover, and follow the manufacturer on installation, anchors, and walking.

[NEEDS INFO: confirm the cover types and brands we currently install (solar, mesh, solid, automatic, manual) and any ASTM or similar language we should use.]

Automatic safety covers

These open and close on tracks, usually from a switch or a keypad, in a short amount of time. The everyday benefit is that the pool can be covered between uses. In winter, many owners leave the automatic cover closed.

If you do that, plan on a cover pump on the fabric all season, a water level under the cover that stays in the manufacturer's range (Coverstar, as one example, says no more than 5 inches below normal), and a rule you'll actually follow: don't operate the cover with water, snow, or ice on it. Winter use may also be treated differently in the warranty. Coverstar, for one, does not warrant damage due to winter use.

Check your cover manufacturer's instructions. An automatic cover is a system: fabric, tracks, mechanism, pump. It isn't a tarp.

Solid safety cover installed on a Legacy Backyards pool
Automatic pool cover mechanism being installed by Legacy Backyards

Mesh safety covers

Mesh covers typically stretch over the pool and attach to deck anchors with springs. Water can pass through, so you aren't pumping a pond off the top. Light and some debris can also reach the water. Spring opening may include more algae or dirt below the cover, which is why our opening notes treat mesh as its own case.

The cover still needs to be tight, anchored correctly, and cleared of heavy debris. It's a winter and safety product, not a daily on-and-off cover.

Solid safety covers

Solid anchored covers block more sunlight and debris. Rain and snowmelt sit on top, so you need a way to pump that water off. Winter care looks a little more like automatic-cover care, even though the hardware is different. Follow the manufacturer on water level, pump use, and whether anyone may walk on the cover.

A solar blanket is not a winter safety cover

A solar or thermal blanket can help with heat and evaporation in season. It is not a substitute for a safety cover or a winter cover in this climate. If you use one, store it properly when you close the pool.

How we'd help you choose

How often do you want the pool covered in summer? How do you feel about a bigger spring cleanup? Do you want one system year-round? And what's the budget once the mechanism, the pump, and the anchors are included? On a new job, the cover should be in the original quote, not a leftover. If you already have a pool, ask whether a retrofit is something we'll do. [NEEDS INFO: confirm retrofit policy.]

We can walk through the options in a consultation.

FAQs

Which cover is best for Illinois winters?
The one that's a real safety cover, installed to the manufacturer's instructions, and actually maintained. Automatic, mesh, and solid can all be used here. They just ask different things of you.

Do I still need a fence if I have an automatic cover?
Often yes. A cover is not automatically a substitute for a required barrier. See permits and fencing.

Can I leave an automatic cover closed all winter?
Many people do, with a cover pump and the correct water level. Read the warranty and the winter guide for your brand first.

Will a mesh cover keep the water clean?
It will keep most large debris out. It will not keep the water as dark or as still as a solid or automatic cover.

Let’s start with a conversation

Request a consultation

Share how your family wants to use the backyard, and we’ll set up a free design consultation.

Request your free consultation

Call 217-671-6171 Contact us

Monday through Friday, 9:00 AM to 5:00 PM. Closed weekends. 230 N. Chicago St., Lincoln, IL 62656.

Legacy Backyards

Building Your Family’s Legacy

Let’s build the place everyone comes home to.